Running a challenge match campaign is a fantastic way for nonprofits to boost donations, engage donors, and create a sense of urgency around fundraising. But for smaller nonprofits, the idea of running a challenge match can seem daunting, especially when resources are limited. However, with the right strategy and tools, smaller nonprofits can successfully implement challenge matches, drive greater engagement, and maximize their fundraising efforts.

In this blog post, we’ll share actionable strategies specifically for smaller organizations to successfully run challenge match campaigns. We’ll discuss how to source matches through engaged website visitors, reduce the administrative burden, and leverage tools that streamline the process. This includes:

For smaller nonprofits, challenge matches offer an exciting opportunity to drive donations and create excitement around fundraising. Ready to learn how your organization can pull off such a campaign effectively? Let’s begin.

Why Challenge Matches Are Effective for Smaller Nonprofits

Challenge matches are an incredibly effective fundraising tool for nonprofits of all sizes. For smaller organizations, these campaigns can have an outsized impact. Here’s why:

  • Amplified Donations: A challenge match motivates donors to give more, knowing their gift will be matched, often doubling or even tripling their impact. For small nonprofits, this can significantly increase the funds raised in a short period.
  • Increased Donor Engagement: Challenge matches create a sense of urgency and excitement, motivating donors to give more. Eager supporters want to be part of a goal, and knowing their contributions are part of something larger motivates them to participate more actively.
  • Attracting New Donors: The matching opportunity can increase your organization’s visibility and attract new donors who may be more inclined to give if they know their gift will be matched. It provides them with a sense of greater impact and fulfillment.
  • Maximizing Limited Resources: Challenge matches make the most of your fundraising efforts. Rather than relying solely on increasing the number of donors or raising larger individual gifts, a match amplifies the success of each donation, allowing you to stretch your resources even further.

Challenge matches can help small nonprofits punch above their weight, driving more donations, engagement, and visibility in ways that align perfectly with their goals. Let’s explore a few best practices for how you can do so.

Sourcing Matches via Website Visitors

One way smaller nonprofits can source matches is by leveraging their existing website visitors. After all, many engaged website users are already interested in your mission and are more likely to become donors or match sponsors.

Here’s how you can make the most of your website visitors to source challenge match donors:

  • Utilize Website Enrichment Tools: Enhance your website visitor data by leveraging tools that offer insights into the companies or organizations to which they belong. You can identify potential corporate sponsors or challenge match donors among your visitors, giving you valuable leads.
  • Create Targeted Campaigns: Use your website data to segment visitors based on engagement levels or areas of interest. Create specific targeted campaigns for these visitors, encouraging them to participate in a challenge match.
  • Implement Exit-Intent Popups: Use exit-intent popups to capture website visitors who are about to leave the site. Offer them an opportunity to engage in the challenge match by highlighting how their donation could be doubled, making it more compelling for them to take action before they leave.
  • Leverage Social Proof: Showcase testimonials, donations, or successful match campaigns directly on your website. Seeing others participate in your challenge match can motivate website visitors to contribute or become match sponsors themselves.
  • Add a Call-to-Action on High-Traffic Pages: Ensure that pages with high visitor traffic, such as your homepage, blog, or donation page, prominently feature calls to action for your challenge match. A simple, well-placed CTA can guide visitors to become more involved in your fundraising efforts.
  • Use Google’s Ad Grants Program: Take advantage of Google’s Ad Grants program to promote your challenge match through no-cost paid advertising. With this program, small nonprofits can run search ads targeting individuals who are looking for causes to support, driving more visitors to your challenge match campaign without straining your budget.

Sourcing matches from website visitors helps you tap into an already engaged audience, making it easier to secure both donations and matching gifts.

Reducing Administrative Burden with the Right Tools

Smaller nonprofits often face resource constraints, and managing a challenge match campaign can be a challenging and time-consuming task. However, using the right tools can significantly reduce the burden. Here’s how to streamline the process:

  • Enlist a Donor Management System (or CRM): Use a robust donor management system or CRM to track donations, monitor progress, and keep detailed records of match contributions. Many DMS platforms also offer automated tools to help with reporting and communications.
  • Automate Communication: Utilize email or social media marketing platforms to streamline donor communication, including automated thank-you emails, progress updates, and reminders about the match deadline. Digital marketing automation saves time and ensures your donors are engaged throughout the campaign.
  • Leverage User-Friendly Event and Donation Pages: Use website builders or fundraising platforms that offer customizable donation pages specifically designed for challenge match campaigns. These tools can handle the donation process and track match progress while giving your donors an easy, engaging experience.
  • Utilize Analytics and Reporting Tools: Implement tools that track visitor behavior on your website, monitor campaign performance, and analyze the effectiveness of your outreach efforts. These insights help you optimize your campaign strategies and identify opportunities for additional matches or donor engagement.

By using tools that automate and simplify the process, you can significantly reduce the administrative workload and focus on driving campaign success. These resources will enable you to make the most of your challenge match, regardless of your organization’s size.

Engaging Your Donor Base for Maximum Participation

For smaller nonprofits, engaging your existing donor base is crucial to the success of your challenge match. Here’s how you can increase participation:

  • Personalized Outreach: Reach out to major donors personally, letting them know about the match opportunity. Personal touches can motivate higher-value contributions and secure match sponsors.
  • Social Media Engagement: Use social media to build excitement around the challenge match. Regular posts that highlight progress, donor stories, and deadlines can keep your supporters engaged and motivated to contribute.
  • Peer-to-Peer Fundraising: Encourage your current donors to become advocates for the challenge match. By leveraging their networks, you can expand your reach and inspire new contributions.

Engaging your existing donor base and expanding your reach through advocacy is essential for achieving a successful challenge match campaign.

Tracking Donations and Progress Efficiently

Efficient tracking of donations is crucial for monitoring the success of your challenge match campaign. Here’s how to stay on top of donations:

  • Real-Time Donation Tracking: Use a donor management system that provides real-time updates on donations. This helps you keep track of both match and non-match donations, ensuring your campaign stays on track for success.
  • Progress Updates for Donors: Regularly update donors on your progress toward meeting the match goal. Real-time progress bars on your website or social media posts keep the excitement alive and encourage more donations overall.
  • Donor Insights: Analyze which donor segments are responding best to the match and tailor your outreach accordingly. For example, if certain demographics are more likely to participate, direct your efforts toward those groups.

By tracking donations and progress in real-time, you can stay proactive and ensure that you’re meeting your fundraising targets. If not, you can use the information you gathered to make any necessary judgment calls and adjust your efforts accordingly.

Wrapping Up & Next Steps

Challenge match campaigns offer a unique and powerful way for smaller nonprofits to boost donations and drive engagement. By sourcing matches from website visitors, using the right tools to reduce administrative burden, and engaging donors effectively, smaller nonprofits can run successful and impactful challenge match campaigns.

Today, it’s time to maximize the success of your challenge match and ensure that every donation makes a meaningful impact. Good luck!

Explore Employee Matching Gifts for Even More Fundraising Success

If you’re looking to further boost your fundraising efforts, consider integrating employee matching gift programs into your challenge match campaign. Double the Donation’s tools help you identify, track, and maximize these matching gift opportunities. Request a demo today to discover how you can enhance your campaign and raise even more funds through employee matching gifts.

Raise more for your cause with employee matching gifts.